Table of Contents
    Current image: First Article Inspection: 7 Proven Rules for Full vs Partial FAI

    First Article Inspection: Rules for Full vs Partial FAI

    First article inspection (FAI) verifies that a production process can make a part that meets the drawing and customer requirements. Aerospace suppliers use AS9102 to structure the First Article Inspection Report (FAIR). A full FAI documents the complete part and process for a new or qualifying production article. A partial or delta FAI documents the changes and affected characteristics when an existing article changes. The customer’s purchase order and quality clauses control the exact obligation.

    The decision depends on more than whether a part is new or changed. The supplier must determine whether a change affects form, fit, function, process, location, tooling, material, or other customer-defined triggers. Ideagen’s AS9102 guide explains the three report forms and common FAI triggers, while Composites Universal discusses full versus partial FAI in a composite-parts context. This guide turns those ideas into a decision process for machine shops and aerospace suppliers.

    What is first article inspection?

    First article inspection is a documented verification of the part’s design characteristics and the manufacturing process used to produce it. The team compares drawing and specification requirements with objective evidence from the actual production part. Depending on the contract, the FAIR can include dimensional results, material certificates, special-process records, functional tests and traceability data.

    FAI is different from a normal in-process or final inspection. A routine inspection checks selected features on recurring production. A first article package provides a baseline showing that the process, tooling, programming, suppliers and inspection plan can produce the complete part to the required revision. It also creates a reference for later changes.

    AS9102 organizes the FAIR into three forms. Form 1 identifies the part and the FAI status. Form 2 lists materials, processes and relevant supplier or process references. Form 3 records the design characteristics, their requirements, results and the method of verification. The supplier should use the current customer-required revision and the exact contract flow-down. Ideagen’s guide describes the forms and accountability structure, while 3ERP’s FAI overview explains why the inspection supports manufacturing quality and customer confidence.

    When is a full FAI required?

    A full FAI is generally used when a new part number or new production process has no approved baseline FAIR. It establishes the complete set of characteristics and evidence for the initial production article. A customer may also require a full FAI after a significant change or when the supplier cannot demonstrate that prior records remain valid.

    The supplier should review the purchase order, customer quality clauses, drawing revision, process plan and prior FAIR before deciding. If the previous report is missing, incomplete or tied to an obsolete process, a full FAI may be the most defensible route. Do not assume that a part is covered because a similar part from the same family has an accepted FAIR.

    A full FAI normally requires the team to:

    1. Confirm the part number, revision, material and applicable specifications.
    2. Identify each design characteristic that must be reported.
    3. Balloon or otherwise link each characteristic to the drawing.
    4. Record actual measurement results and verification methods.
    5. Attach material, process, test and supplier certifications.
    6. Confirm that the article came from the production process or a customer-approved representative process.
    7. Review the FAIR for completeness before submission.

    The exact report content depends on the standard revision and customer requirements. Customer clauses may add records or define different triggers. The quality manager should keep the decision rationale with the FAIR.

    When is a partial or delta FAI acceptable?

    A partial FAI documents a change to an established product baseline. The supplier reports the affected characteristics and supporting evidence while referencing the previously accepted FAIR for unchanged items. It is appropriate only when the prior report is available, valid and traceable to the same part number and relevant process.

    Common situations that may trigger a delta review include a drawing revision, a change in tooling or manufacturing process, a supplier or facility change, a material change, a move in production location, a lapse in production, or a process change that affects characteristics. The standard and customer contract define the actual triggers. The supplier should not treat the examples as an exhaustive substitute for the governing requirement.

    Change scenario

    FAI decision to assess

    Evidence to review

    New part number or no valid baseline FAIR

    Full FAI is commonly required

    Complete design characteristics and production records

    Drawing revision changes dimensions or notes

    Delta may cover affected characteristics; customer rules may require more

    Revision comparison, updated ballooning and results

    Material or special process changes

    Assess affected properties and related characteristics

    New certificates, test data and supplier approval

    Tooling, program or process route changes

    Assess whether form, fit or function could be affected

    Process validation, first-piece results and dimensional data

    Production moves to a different facility

    Review customer/standard triggers and process equivalence

    Site approval, equipment, personnel and process evidence

    Long production lapse or inactive process

    Review lapse rules and process stability

    Current process capability and renewed first-piece evidence

    The table is a decision aid, not an AS9102 interpretation. When the standard or customer clause is unclear, ask the customer quality representative before submitting a partial report. A rejected FAIR can delay shipment and create confusion about what the supplier actually verified.

    How should a supplier decide between full and partial FAI?

    How should a supplier decide between full and partial FAI? — Show a decision flow that starts by checking for a valid, traceable accepted ba

    Use a controlled decision process. First, identify the last accepted FAIR and confirm that it covers the same part number, revision and production location. Next, compare the current design and process with that baseline. List every changed input, including drawing characteristics, material, special process, tooling, program, supplier, machine, location and inspection method.

    Then map each change to affected design characteristics. A change to a material specification can affect mechanical properties, corrosion, heat treatment and tests. A tooling change can affect dimensions, surface condition and process capability. A software revision can alter tool paths and machined features. The team should look beyond the feature that triggered the change and consider downstream characteristics.

    Finally, check customer-specific requirements and determine whether the change meets a full-FAI trigger. If a partial is acceptable, identify the unaffected characteristics by reference to the accepted baseline and include evidence for all affected items. If the baseline cannot be retrieved or the impact cannot be bounded, escalate for customer direction or complete a full FAI.

    A practical internal review can be signed by engineering, quality and the process owner. Purchasing or supplier quality should confirm that outside processors and material suppliers have supplied current records. The decision should be recorded even when a new FAIR is not required. That record helps later auditors understand why the team chose the scope.

    What belongs in AS9102 Forms 1, 2 and 3?

    What belongs in AS9102 Forms 1, 2 and 3? — Use three cards to explain each form’s role: Form 1 for part identity and FAI status, Form 2 for

    Form 1 identifies the part, revision, FAIR type and relevant product information. The status should make clear whether the report is full or partial and point to any prior baseline used for a delta report.

    Form 2 captures material and process accountability. List raw material, special processes, functional tests and relevant supplier or processor information. Attach certificates or references so the reviewer can trace the reported evidence. The form should reflect the actual production route, not a generic routing that was never used for the article.

    Form 3 accounts for design characteristics. Each characteristic should map to a drawing or specification requirement, show the actual result, identify the measurement or verification method, and include the result status. If a characteristic is not applicable, use the customer-accepted convention and explain the basis. Avoid unexplained blanks, copied values or results that do not match the drawing revision.

    Report form

    Main purpose

    Common gap to avoid

    Form 1

    Part identity, revision and FAI status

    Wrong revision or unclear full/partial designation

    Form 2

    Materials, processes, tests and supplier traceability

    Missing outside-process or certificate references

    Form 3

    Characteristic-by-characteristic results

    Unclear balloons, missing methods or actual values copied from nominal

    Composites Universal’s guide highlights composite-specific expectations and the full-versus-partial decision, while Ideagen focuses on AS9102 Rev C and Form 1, 2 and 3 accountability. A machine shop should adapt the evidence to its actual materials, processes and customer clauses.

    How should ballooning and characteristic accountability work?

    A balloon drawing assigns a unique identifier to each reportable characteristic. The FAIR uses those identifiers to connect the drawing to measurement results and supporting records. Ballooning should follow the drawing revision being inspected. If a note, dimension or reference changes, update the drawing and report together.

    Do not balloon only the dimensions that are easy to measure. Include notes, material requirements, surface finish, threads, special characteristics and other customer-controlled requirements when required by the standard or contract. For a profile or complex geometry, define the inspection method and report how the result was evaluated. If a characteristic is verified by a supplier certificate or test report, include its traceable reference.

    The report should show actual measurements, not just “pass” when the customer or standard expects values. If a dimension is measured at multiple locations, identify the sampling method. If a gage or CMM is used, retain the program or inspection record where required. A reviewer should be able to trace from the balloon to the result and understand how the measurement was obtained.

    What are common FAI mistakes in a machine shop?

    Common problems include using the wrong drawing revision, missing characteristics, incomplete outside-process records, incorrect material certificates, unapproved substitutions, and treating a partial FAI as a simple subset without a valid baseline. Another frequent error is recording nominal values instead of actual measurement results.

    A shop can prevent these errors with a pre-submission checklist. Verify that the article was made using the intended production route, that all special processes are complete, and that the certificate package matches the lot. Check every Form 3 entry against the drawing and ballooning. Have a second reviewer compare the report with the contract and customer clauses.

    Do not create a FAIR from a prototype made by a different process unless the customer approves that approach. A machined billet prototype may not represent a production casting or forging. If production tooling, supplier or location changes after the article, reassess whether the first article still represents the released process.

    How should a supplier control FAI records and changes?

    Keep the accepted baseline FAIR with the part’s configuration record. The file should include the report, ballooned drawing, material certifications, special-process records, measurement data, approvals and customer correspondence. Make the records searchable by part number, revision, serial or lot where applicable.

    A process change should trigger a documented review. The change owner should identify the affected characteristics, required customer approvals, new tests and whether a full or partial FAI applies. Notify the customer before shipment when the contract requires approval. Store the approved report and change decision together so later production does not rely on an outdated FAIR.

    How should FAI triggers be mapped to part changes?

    Compare each change with the current drawing, process and customer clauses. A change can affect more than one characteristic. The team should list the change, identify the affected requirement, decide what evidence is needed and record whether the baseline remains valid. Do not use a single checklist as a substitute for reading the contract and the current standard.

    Change

    Questions for the supplier

    Possible FAI scope to assess

    New part number

    Is there an accepted baseline FAIR?

    Full FAI is commonly used to establish the baseline

    Drawing revision

    Which dimensions, notes or materials changed?

    Delta on affected and related characteristics, if allowed

    Material substitution

    Did chemistry, condition or properties change?

    Review material and affected mechanical or process characteristics

    New supplier or outside processor

    Does the source or process affect product requirements?

    Review certificates, special-process records and customer approval

    Tooling or CNC program change

    Could the change alter fit, form, function or special characteristics?

    Validate affected dimensions and related features

    Facility or production-location move

    Are equipment, process and controls equivalent?

    Check standard/customer triggers and approval requirements

    Process route change

    Did the sequence, heat treatment or inspection change?

    Evaluate all characteristics influenced by the new route

    Extended production lapse

    Does the current process still match the approved baseline?

    Review current requirements and any lapse rules

    The table is for planning. A customer may require a full FAI even when the supplier believes the affected scope is limited. When a trigger is ambiguous, document the question and seek written direction before shipment.

    What does a machine-shop FAI change example look like?

    Consider a bracket with a new drawing revision that changes a hole location and adds a surface-finish note. The supplier compares revisions, updates the ballooned drawing, confirms the CNC program and setup sheet, then measures the changed hole and surface. The quality team also checks related datums and any characteristic whose result depends on the moved hole. If the contract permits a partial FAI and the baseline is valid, the FAIR can reference unchanged characteristics while presenting new evidence for the affected items.

    Now consider a supplier moving the same bracket from one machine shop to another. Even if the drawing is unchanged, equipment, fixtures, operator methods and inspection controls may differ. The supplier should review the standard and customer clauses, validate the new process, and determine whether a full or partial FAI is required. A report from the previous site does not automatically establish the new site’s capability.

    A third example is a material substitution. If the new material changes strength, heat treatment, coating or machinability, the scope may extend beyond Form 2. The team should identify affected Form 3 characteristics and supporting test records. If the substitution is not approved by the customer, the supplier should not release it as equivalent based on a catalog comparison alone.

    What evidence makes a partial FAI defensible?

    A partial FAI needs a clear link to an accepted baseline and a defensible scope. The file should identify the prior FAIR, part number and revision, describe the change, list affected characteristics and show the actual results. It should also retain the supporting records for material, special processes, tests and customer approval where required.

    A useful change-impact record answers:

    1. What changed and why?
    2. Which requirements or characteristics could be affected?
    3. Which characteristics were remeasured or reverified?
    4. Which baseline records remain applicable, and why?
    5. Who reviewed the scope and who accepted it?
    6. What new supplier, process or test evidence is attached?

    A report that says “partial FAI” but does not show the change logic is hard to review. The customer should be able to see how the supplier bounded the impact. If the scope cannot be bounded, a full FAI or customer direction may be safer.

    What common FAIR errors cause customer rejection?

    Many rejected reports fail because the paperwork does not match the actual part. Common examples include the wrong drawing revision, missing characteristics, blank Form 3 results, nominal values copied in place of actual measurements, and certificates that do not identify the production lot. A customer may also reject a partial report if it lacks the prior baseline or does not justify why unchanged characteristics remain valid.

    A machine shop can prevent these gaps with a pre-submission review. Verify the ballooned drawing, report forms, material certificates, outside-process records, actual measurement results and revision identifiers. Confirm that every special characteristic has an accepted result and that any not-applicable item follows customer rules. Have a second reviewer compare the package with the purchase order and quality clauses.

    If a report is rejected, keep the original submission and the customer’s comments. Correct the record with traceable changes rather than replacing files without explanation. If the rejection reveals a process gap, open a corrective action and check whether other FAIR packages may have the same issue.

    How should FAI records stay current after approval?

    Treat the FAIR as a baseline tied to product configuration. Store it with the drawing revision, process flow, material and supplier records. When a change occurs, link the new review to the accepted report so future teams can see the history. Keep the previous version available; do not erase the audit trail.

    The quality system should assign an owner for part-number and revision control, establish a trigger-review step at engineering change, and notify suppliers when the customer changes a clause. If a production process moves or a supplier changes, the team should review the risk before the next lot ships. The FAI decision should be recorded even if the team concludes that no new report is required.

    How should a shop organize FAI measurement and review?

    Start with the latest customer-approved drawing and the traveler for the production article. The quality engineer should confirm that the ballooned drawing matches the revision on the order and that each characteristic has a defined inspection method. Use a CMM, hand gage, visual check, material certificate or process record as appropriate. The report should name the method and show actual results when the standard or customer expects measured values.

    Measurements need a clear reference. Define datums, alignment, units and sampling method. A complex profile may require a CMM program and a saved report. A thread may need a plug gage plus a thread callout check. A surface finish requirement may require a profilometer or customer-specific method. The supplier should document the equipment ID and calibration status when required by the quality plan.

    Review the FAIR before sending it to the customer. Compare the report with the ballooned drawing, purchase order, material certificate, outside-process records and revision history. Check that no characteristic is missing, that actual results are not copied from nominal values, and that each attachment refers to the same lot. A second-person review catches mismatched revisions and incomplete records before the package reaches the customer.

    If the article fails a characteristic, stop and decide whether the product is nonconforming. Record the actual result, contain related parts and follow the disposition process. Do not alter the reported value to make the report pass. If an engineering concession is needed, get customer approval and link the approval to the affected characteristic and lot.

    How should customers review a submitted FAIR?

    The customer reviewer should confirm the part number and revision, compare the report with the purchase order, and check whether the full or partial scope is justified. For a partial report, verify that the baseline FAIR is available and that the change analysis covers related characteristics, not only the obvious dimension.

    Review each Form 3 entry against the balloon drawing and GDT requirements. Check that the characteristic is readable, the result is an actual measurement or approved verification, and the method is traceable. Then match certificates and special-process records to the part lot. If a third-party processor performed heat treatment, plating or another controlled process, make sure its evidence is current and linked to the actual article.

    If the report has an omission, return a specific comment that identifies the characteristic or record needed. Avoid a generic rejection note that leaves the supplier guessing. The supplier should preserve the original package, respond with a revision, and explain any correction. Both sides benefit when the acceptance record clearly identifies the approved FAIR version.

    What conclusion should an aerospace supplier draw?

    At Align Manufacturing, we can review a supplier’s first-article workflow and manufacturing records. Use a full FAI to establish a complete baseline and a partial FAI only when the accepted baseline and customer rules support that scope. Contact our team with the part revision, process route and customer clauses so the documentation plan can be checked before submission.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What does FAI stand for?

    FAI means First Article Inspection. The report documents that a production article meets the drawing and customer requirements.

    What is the difference between full and partial FAI?

    A full FAI establishes the complete baseline. A partial or delta FAI documents affected characteristics after a change, using a valid prior report for unchanged items.

    What is AS9102?

    AS9102 is an aerospace standard used to structure first article inspection reporting. Use the current customer-required revision and clauses.

    What triggers a partial FAI?

    A design, material, process, tooling, supplier, location or production change may trigger a delta review. The standard and customer contract define the actual requirements.

    What are AS9102 Forms 1, 2 and 3?

    Form 1 identifies the part and FAI status, Form 2 records material and process accountability, and Form 3 lists design characteristics and results.

    Does every drawing revision require a full FAI?

    Not always. Assess the change, affected characteristics, previous FAIR and customer rules. Some changes may be documented through a partial FAI.

    Can a prototype be used for FAI?

    Only if it represents the production process or the customer approves the approach. A prototype made by a different route may not establish production capability.

    How long should a supplier retain a FAIR?

    Retention follows the contract, customer requirements and applicable quality-system rules. Keep the FAIR traceable to the part and revision through manufacturing documentation control and material traceability.

    Who approves a partial FAI?

    The supplier quality process prepares it, and the customer or authorized representative may need to accept it under the contract.

    Align Manufacturing

    Align Manufacturing

    Align Manufacturing is a Western owned and operated engineering and manufacturing company with local staff, to help you effectively source your industrial parts for US projects from South and South East Asia.